Cosmology Shrieks in the Dark | CEH

October 30, 2020 | David F. Coppedge

Secular cosmologists preserve spending increasingly more cash on the lookout for darkish matter. To this point it’s all trick and no deal with.

The search for darkish matter is approaching half a century with no luck. Repeated guarantees that astronomers “are getting hotter” preserve failing. Nonetheless, nations are spending prodigious quantities of cash to construct larger and extra delicate detectors. If cosmologists don’t discover the mysterious unknown stuff quickly, the “exhausting science” of physics will endure a devastating blow. Darkish matter might go down within the historical past of science because the phlogiston of the 21st century.

Final likelihood for WIMPs: physicists launch all-out hunt for dark-matter candidate (Nature). The USA, Italy and China are competing to improve their big underground detectors in a last-ditch effort to search out “Weakly Interactive Large Particles” (WIMPs), giant subatomic particles which can be favored darkish matter candidates. Italy’s detector is called “DARWIN.” Filling these big tanks with supercooled xenon is costing a lot of the worldwide finances of the noble gasoline. Is it price it for one thing that will not even exist?

Physicists may need no alternative however to membership collectively due to the sheer amount of xenon wanted. The noble gasoline is tough to acquire in giant portions owing to the energy-intensive course of wanted to extract it from the air and due to competing demand from electronics, lighting and area industries. One kilogram can price greater than US$2,500. Darwin’s 50 tonnes could be near the world’s annual manufacturing of round 70 tonnes, which means that — even when all three present detectors mix their 25 tonnes — a future experiment would wish to purchase the remaining in batches over a number of years. “We now have to plan very rigorously for it already now,” says Baudis.

A brand new approach to seek for darkish matter reveals hidden supplies properties ( In the meantime, physicists on the Chalmers Institute of Know-how are describing properties of one thing that will not exist. “The brand new calculations allow theorists to make detailed predictions concerning the nature and energy of interactions between darkish matter and electrons, which had been not beforehand attainable.” Really, it’s attainable to foretell the properties of something that’s all free parameters and no knowledge.

We all know little or no about darkish matter, aside from that it exists.

The puzzle of the unusual galaxy product of 99.99% darkish matter is solved (Institute of Astrophysics, Canary Islands). How might an entire galaxy be made up of stuff that will not exist? It could’t. The scientists who introduced the galaxy had been mistaken. One other look confirmed that galaxy Dragonfly 44 has no extra darkish matter than different galaxies – that’s, if they’ve any in any respect. Darkish matter will not be detected straight; it’s inferred from the motions of matter.

New idea on the origin of Darkish Matter (University of Melbourne). It simply bubbled up, easy ones, through the Massive Bang. That’s why it’s so exhausting to detect. Aren’t you glad that’s solved?

“These section transitions are anticipated to have taken place within the early universe and might be much like bubbles of gasoline forming in boiling water.  We present that it’s pure to anticipate darkish matter particles to search out it very tough enter [sic] these bubbles, which supplies a brand new clarification for the quantity of darkish matter noticed within the universe.”

However it isn’t noticed. It’s inferred. It’s just like the mysterious “inflaton” particle that was concocted to clarify cosmic inflation, which Alan Guth concocted. When idea requires a particle, scientists will search perpetually to search out it till a scientific revolution happens that now not wants the particle as a result of it now not trusts the idea.

Highest-yet decision picture of darkish matter.

Precision metrology closes in on darkish matter ( They don’t know what it’s, but when they discover it, they’ll have the ability to measure it to higher precision than ever. Let’s hope their instruments can discover different makes use of in case darkish matter by no means turns up.

The existence of darkish matter is not directly evident from gravitational results at galactic and cosmological scales, however past that, little is thought of its nature. One of many results that falls out of theoretical evaluation of darkish matter coupling to particles in the usual mannequin of physics is a ensuing oscillation in elementary constants. Ye and collaborators figured that if their world-class metrology gear couldn’t detect these oscillations, then this apparently null outcome could be helpful affirmation that the energy of darkish matter interactions with particles in the usual mannequin of physics have to be even decrease than dictated by the constraints to this point on document.

A Billion Tiny Pendulums Might Detect the Universe’s Lacking Mass (National Institute of Standards, NIST). Overlook the underground xenon; this group thinks “a billion millimeter-sized pendulums would act as darkish matter sensors.” Who’s going to construct these? Possibly the businesses that make good telephones might assist.

To manufacture so many tiny sensors, the staff means that researchers might need to borrow methods that the smartphone and automotive industries already use to supply giant numbers of mechanical detectors.

Due to the sensitivity of the person detectors, researchers using the expertise needn’t confine themselves to the darkish facet.

However do firms working to make a revenue need to blow that a lot cash on a 50-year fruitless quest?

A Main Milestone for an Underground Darkish Matter Search Experiment (Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory). They reached a “main milestone” in constructing their costly detector, however NOT a serious milestone to find the mysterious WIMPs. The final model of their xenon-filled underground LUX detector discovered nothing (22 Nov 2019, 21 July 2016). This quest for nothing is funded by the DOE (US Dept of Power). Your tax {dollars} at work.

“We’ve actually finished this earlier than, however by no means at this scale,” he stated. LUX used about one-third of a metric ton of liquid xenon, whereas LZ can have 10 metric tons of liquid xenon and will probably be about 100 instances extra delicate to darkish matter particle interactions.

“We’re going into the unknown now.”

Darkish matter: our methodology for catching ghostly haloes might assist unveil what it’s product of (The Conversation). Andrea Font traces the seek for darkish matter again 70 years.

The seek for darkish matter – an unknown and invisible substance thought to make up the overwhelming majority of matter within the universe – is at a crossroads. Though it was proposed practically 70 years in the past and has been looked for intensely – with giant particle colliders, detectors deep underground and even devices in area – it’s nonetheless nowhere to be discovered.

So how do you retain a 70-year search going? Promissory notes work. ‘Oh, however suppose how essential phlogiston will probably be if we ever discover it! It’d even remedy most cancers and remedy world warming!’

Darkish matter stays a thriller, however there’s an enormous quantity of labor going into fixing it. Whether or not the reply will come from devices on Earth or astrophysical probes, it should little doubt be probably the most essential discoveries of the century.

Distant alien planets might be become darkish matter detectors (Live Science). Astrophysicist Paul Sutter illustrates the overconfidence of cosmologists of their idea: “We all know little or no about darkish matter, aside from that it exists,” he states with Tontological bravado. Possibly scientists might flip exoplanets into darkish matter detectors. Why not? Nothing else works. However will the mission planners of the James Webb Area Telescope, scheduled to launch (lastly) late subsequent yr, be prepared to surrender valuable time to look at 1000’s of exoplanet temperatures, as Sutter suggests? Don’t depend on it. The mega-expensive infrared area telescope has a lifetime of 6-10 years, and after quite a few delays and price overruns, making astronomers wait for nearly 20 years to get the factor off the bottom, they will be very specific about observing priorities.

Particle Physicists Proceed To Make Empty Guarantees (BackReaction blog). In textual content and video, cosmologist Sabine Hossenfelder complains that every one this discuss darkish matter is teasing the general public with unfalsifiable bravado.

Let me unwrap this for you. The declare that darkish matter is a assured outcome, adopted by weasel phrases about weakly interacting and thermal origin, is the physics equal of claiming “We’ll develop a brand new drug with the assured results of curing most cancers” adopted by weasel phrases to clarify, nicely, really it should remedy a kind of most cancers that exists solely theoretically and has by no means been noticed in actuality. That’s how “assured” this supposed darkish matter result’s. They assure to rule out some very particular hypotheses for darkish matter that we’ve got no motive to suppose are right within the first place.

A lot of theories are “falsifiable” in precept, she explains. That doesn’t imply they’re scientific. ” There are many falsifiable hypotheses which can be clearly unscientific,” she says with examples, corresponding to predictions of what’s going to occur tomorrow when there isn’t a motive to anticipate the occasion. To this point, she goes on, cosmologists are looking for darkish matter by ruling out prospects. Is {that a} scientific strategy?

The identical is the case with particle physicists’ hypotheses for darkish matter that you’re “assured” to rule out with that costly huge collider. Particle physicists actually have 1000’s of theories for darkish matter, some thousandths of which have already been dominated out. Can they assure {that a} subsequent bigger collider can rule out some extra? Sure. What’s the assured data we are going to achieve from this? Nicely, the identical because the achieve that we’ve got gotten so removed from ruling out their darkish matter hypotheses, which is that we nonetheless don’t know what darkish matter is. We don’t even know it’s a particle to start with.


In some unspecified time in the future, after a lot attempting and a lot expense, astronomers might have to simply resolve it’s not price it to pursue this darkish imaginative and prescient any longer. The intense daybreak of All Saints Day will overwhelm the haunting gloom of the witches’ Sabbath.

Maybe the answer is to kick the moyboys out and take severely the concept we dwell in a younger cosmos. That might not be an inexpensive trick. Saving a lot cash could be a deal with.




(Visited 414 instances, 1 visits immediately)


Recent Articles

Related Stories

Leave a Reply

Subscribe to Blog via Email